We have been in the playoff era for three years. Obviously, having an excellent team is a prerequisite for making the playoffs, but how does scheduling affect a school’s playoff chances?
FB Schedules looked at the data and provide the following Ten Commandants of Playoff scheduling:
I. You MUST schedule a Power school out of conference play.
100% of the 12 teams who earned slots in the first three CFB Playoff brackets played a Power team in non-conference play. It is one of only two absolutes among the dozen Playoff-worthy slates.
II. Schedule your bye week for Week 6 or later.
Of the 12 previous Playoff schools, nine (or 75%) had at least one bye week that fell during or after Week 6 of the season.
The only exceptions were Ohio State in 2016 (the Buckeyes had Week 4 off), Clemson in 2015 (also Week 4), and Oklahoma in 2015 (Week 3).
III. Schedule no more than two road games in a row.
The other absolute in scheduling for a Playoff, 100% of the teams sampled played a maximum of two consecutive road games during the regular season.
Of these, five (or 42%) didn’t play any back-to-back road games during their Playoff campaign (2016 Clemson, 2015 Alabama and Oklahoma, 2014 Florida State and Oregon.)
IV. Schedule at least three consecutive home games.
The flip side of the third commandment, eight (or 67%) of the 12 Playoff teams scheduled at least one home stand lasting three weeks or more.
In 2015, Michigan State enjoyed a stretch of four home games from Sept. 12 (Oregon) to Oct. 3 (Purdue) – making the Spartans the Playoff team with the longest homestretch in history.
V. There is no need to double-up on non-conference power opponents.
While the first commandment is absolute, schools don’t need to push the boat out too far if they choose not to. Of the 12 Playoff teams, only three (or 25%) scheduled more than one Power team out of conference play. The exceptions are Clemson (two in both 2015 and 2016) and Florida State (three in 2014).
VI. Scheduling an FCS team isn’t a big deal.
Even though FBS teams have won roughly 90 percent of the 240 games they’ve played vs. FCS schools since the CFB Playoff kicked off in 2014, scheduling such an opponent isn’t frowned upon.
Eight of the 12 Playoff teams (or 67%) scheduled an FCS squad and still made the bracket. The only exceptions were Ohio State (2016 and 2014), Michigan State (2015), and Oklahoma (2015).
VII. Schedule at least seven games at home.
Eleven of the 12 playoff teams (or 92%) played seven home games the year they made the playoff. The only exception was Oklahoma in 2015, which played six games at home in Norman, five on the road, and then its standing date with Texas at the Cotton Bowl in Dallas.
What’s worth noting is that five other Playoff teams, like the Sooners, also played a neutral game the year they made it to the bracket. But, each of these—Alabama (2016, 2015 and 2014), Florida State (2014) and Ohio State (2014)—added seven home games and only four road dates to their neutral game.
VIII. Schedule a non-conference power opponent that has a good chance of being ranked.
A proviso to the first commandment, don’t just play any non-conference power opponent, play a good one.
Eight of the 12 Playoff contenders (or 67%) not only played a Power school out of league play, they played such an opponent that was ranked in the Top 25 at the time of the game. The only exceptions were Clemson (2016), Washington (2016), Alabama (2014), and Ohio State (2014).
IX. Schedule a school from any Power conference with the exception of the ACC
To further pinpoint who to play out of conference, pick a school from the Big 12, Big Ten, Pac-12 or SEC. Don’t pick the ACC.
Though it sounds bizarre, of the nine non-ACC teams that have made the Playoff, only one played an ACC team during the regular season. That means 89% of the non-ACC schools scheduled an opponent from another Power conference.
The only exception was (8) Ohio State in 2014, which fell memorably to unranked Virginia Tech in a Week 2 shocker in Columbus.
X. Unless you’re Alabama, schedule 10 Power opponents in the regular season.
The final guideline expands on the fifth commandment. Basically, if you’re not an SEC member, you can’t get away with playing only eight conference games and still make the Playoff.
Currently, the ACC and SEC both play eight-game conference slates while the Big 12, Big Ten, and Pac-12 play nine. Add in the required non-conference Power opponent and the ACC and SEC generally play nine Power teams during a 12-game regular season, while the Big 12, Big Ten, and Pac-12 play ten.
Since Alabama is the only SEC program to ever make the Playoff, we’ll assume that in most cases, the committee would give say Georgia, LSU or Florida the same pass it’s given the Tide. The assumption is that the SEC members’ in-conference schedule is so difficult that it makes up for the fact that the entire league plays one fewer Power team than the rest of the country (minus the ACC).